May 13, 2011, 5:01 pm

American Idol: Down to Three

Well, American Idol has whittled it’s way down to the top three: Lauren Alaina, Haley Reinhart and Scotty McCreery. James Durbin was sent packing last night, which in my opinion, was pretty surprising. In fact, just based on the poll here, it seems it surprised many. This season has actually surprised many with their eliminations. Pia was a surprise elimination that seemed to irritate many of the Idol watchers. In fact, many stopped watching from that point forward. Between the judges not being critical of anyone, the push of certain performers, etc. this season has kinda been a drag to many. In fact, the first time I have heard the judges actually be critical was this week’s performance night, to Haley.

So, why was James eliminated? What made someone who has never found himself in the bottom three suddenly eliminated, and another Idol who has been in the bottom three repeatedly, not only safe from elimination, but not even in the bottom two?

My theory? It comes down to two words: Adam Lambert.

Yes, our old Idol friend Adam Lambert last week endorsed Haley. This came as a surprise to many, since many have been comparing Durbin to Lambert, including James who tried to model himself a bit after him, so we thought Lambert would return the favor and either endorse James, or endorse no one. Well, he endorsed Haley. Many of us have wondered why? That is not to say Haley is not a great singer by any means, but when you ask around, there are many that think Adam may have shown his preference for her because of the competition James may bring him, or that he was tired (or jealous) of hearing people compare James to him. Some of James’ fans have even gone so far as to say he is better than Lambert. So, taking all the chatter around the net about James, it seems Adam made the choice to try and distance himself from The Durbin.

Lambert endorsed Haley all over Twitter. Lambert has over a million followers. So, coincidence? I think not. Did loyal Lambert fans send the rocker packing?

Quite frankly, I don’t think that former Idols should endorse the current contestants, as it gives an unfair advantage, but, that’s just me.

What do you think? Let us know below, then come on in the the FORUM where we are discussing James’ Elimination and have a poll HERE to see if you think Lambert had anything to do with it!

  • DaisyJane26

    Adam Lambert or any former Idol Contestant has every right to speak their mind on who they think is a good performer. James Durbin eliminated himself by being unoriginal, predictable and trying to copy Adam to death.
    He was pitchy and sounded the same everytime. He was cocky and not likeable also. He blew it by himself.
    Don’t blame Adam Lambert for this…It’s nothing but an excuse …look at Durbin for your answer as to why
    he was eliminated. 

  • Mona

    I think you over estimated Adam’s power. 72 million votes did not come from glamberts. FFS Ellen tweeted her support of Haley and she has 6.6 million followers. I blame a combination of the judges, fans thinking he was safe and yes Haley has fans of her own.

  • Anonymous

     James D. didn’t have to copy anybody. He has an exceptional talent and had to overcome not one but two obstacles. He was the most entertaining and should have  won this year. There were a few that were eliminated that should have stayed, for instance Pia. She was the best female vocal, but lacked the personality. Casey had the talent and the personality. Haley was the one that screamed her way through the competition.Everything she sang sounded the same. The growling got to be annoying and sorry but she’s no Janice. I think she displayed some arrogance and that’s why she was finally eliminated. I am very happy for Scotty and Lauren. They stayed consistent and both were very likable. This year was tough to pick a favorite. I hope they all do well.